In recent years, more than 80% of colleges have adopted test-optional policies, meaning students aren’t required to submit SAT or ACT scores with their applications. At first glance, that sounds like great news, right? After all, it’s one less test to stress about! But for many students, skipping the SAT or ACT can actually be a missed opportunity.
What “Test-Optional” Really Means
When a school is test-optional, they’ll review your application without test scores if you choose not to send them. However, optional doesn’t mean irrelevant. Colleges still use test scores as a data point in context with GPA, course rigor, extracurriculars, and other parts of your application. Strong scores can confirm academic readiness and help a student stand out, especially in competitive programs and at selective colleges.
When Submitting Scores Helps
Students should consider submitting test scores when:
- Their SAT or ACT score aligns with or exceeds the school’s middle 50% range (published on each college’s Common Data Set or admission website)
- Their SAT or ACT score aligns with what the admissions team will see on the student’s transcript
- They attend a high school without weighted grades or a rigorous AP/IB curriculum
- Their GPA is solid but not exceptional, and a score can reinforce academic strength
- They’re applying for merit scholarships or direct-entry programs (like nursing, business, or engineering) that often still value test results
In fact, a 2024 study by Compass Education Group found that students who submitted test scores were admitted at higher rates than non-submitters at most selective universities.
When Going Test-Optional Makes Sense
Skipping the SAT or ACT might make sense if:
- The student’s scores fall significantly below the college’s published midrange
- The student has a very strong academic record and unique accomplishments that speak for themselves
- The college is genuinely test-blind (meaning it won’t review scores at all)
It’s worth noting that only a small number of colleges (like the University of California system) are truly test-blind.
A Balanced Strategy
For most students, the best approach is to take a test early (sometime in junior year) and see how they perform. With real data in hand, families can make an informed decision about whether to send scores. Even if a student ultimately applies test-optional, the experience of preparing for a standardized test builds skills in time management, problem-solving, and stamina, all of which help in college.
Bottom line: Test-optional doesn’t mean test-irrelevant. For many students, especially those aiming for merit aid or competitive programs, strong SAT or ACT scores can still open doors.
If you’d like personalized advice on whether your teen should go test-optional or submit scores, I’d be happy to help you strategize. If you have any questions, please reach out to me for a free consultation.
